bell notificationshomepageloginNewPostedit profiledmBox

Hoots : Why SUM(PMT) is not identical to FV? I'm exploring financial functions in a spreadsheet. When I use FV, which is based on FV = PV*(1+r)^n I get a different number than when using PMT and multiplying by the number of periods. - freshhoot.com

10% popularity   0 Reactions

Why SUM(PMT) is not identical to FV?
I'm exploring financial functions in a spreadsheet. When I use FV, which is based on FV = PV*(1+r)^n I get a different number than when using PMT and multiplying by the number of periods.

For example:

Principal: 0,000.00
Interest rate: 2.50%
Interest rate per period: 0.21% (2.50%/12)
Amortization: 25
Num of periods (months): 300 (25*12)
Monthly payment: ,121.54 (PMT(2.5%/12,25*12,-0,000))
Sum of all monthly pmts: 6,462.55 (300*,121.54)
FV function: 6,757.93 (FV(2.5%/12,25*12,0,-0,000))
However, FV(2.5%/12,25*12,21.54,-0,000) return [CO].

In other words, how come FV with "0" monthly payments evaluates at 6k, but FV with 21 monthly payment (which sums up to 6k and not 6k) evaluate at 0?


Load Full (1)

Login to follow hoots

1 Comments

Sorted by latest first Latest Oldest Best

10% popularity   0 Reactions

You're comparing two different scenarios.

FV(2.5%/12,25*12,21.54,-0,000)

This says, I borrowed 0,000 and I want to know how much I will own if I pay off 21.54 each month for 25 years and the interest rate is 2.5%.

That means you're gradually reducing your principal, so the interest accruing each month gradually reduces.

PMT(2.5%/12,25*12,-0,000)*300

This is the total amount you would pay if you paid 21.54 each month.

FV(2.5%/12,25*12,0,-0,000)

This says, I borrowed 0,000 and I want to know how much I will own if I don't pay anything for 25 years and the interest rate is 2.5%.

That means the amount you owe continues to grow, so the extra interest each month will be larger.

This is conceptually similar to a scenario in which you invest a sum of money (0,000) in a 2.5% portfolio, but withdraw 21 on a monthly basis: you would end up with much more if you didn't withdraw at all and waited instead.

The difference between the two scenarios is why, if you take out a mortgage, you should always pay your monthly amount! And why, if you don't, the bank will come after you and foreclose!


Back to top Use Dark theme