bell notificationshomepageloginNewPostedit profiledmBox

Hoots : Is this a helpful way to think about Coltrane Substitution? More specifically, is it harmful? From the ii-V-I I could backtrack from the I and suss out the flatVImaj7 and the IIImaj7, but what about: Bar 1 ii-up a half - freshhoot.com

10% popularity   0 Reactions

Is this a helpful way to think about Coltrane Substitution?
More specifically, is it harmful? From the ii-V-I I could backtrack from the I and suss out the flatVImaj7 and the IIImaj7, but what about:

Bar 1 ii-up a half step to a dominant -

Bar2 down a fourth to a maj7 - up a minor third to a dominant -

Bar 3 down a fourth to a maj7 - up a minor third to a dominant - <-- this is the original V

Bar 4 I


Load Full (1)

Login to follow hoots

1 Comments

Sorted by latest first Latest Oldest Best

10% popularity   0 Reactions

That's a rule of thumb for copying them. If you want to THINK about them, understand two things.

That you can jump to just about ANY chord and start a ii, V, I pattern. And if you jump to one (say) a major third away, then, having completed that sequence jump another major third, you're building a pattern, and patterns are very powerful things in music! When you do something 'wrong' three times over, it starts sounding 'right'!

And the idea of b5 (or 'tritone') substitutions for a chord that has a dominant function.


Back to top Use Dark theme