: Creating melodic/harmonic music with Csound? I am diving into Csound in an effort to gain more control over the creation and manipulation of sound. It is comprehensive, to be sure, but its practitioners seem to be consumed

Vote Up Vote Down   0 Reactions

Login to give Reaction!

Is this a shortcoming of the language, making it exceedingly difficult to focus on these traditional aspects, or is it just that the composers who would choose to use a tool like this are more likely to prioritize other aspects of composition?

It's certainly not a fundamental limitation of the language - CSound and its instrument libraries allow traditional note-based pieces with any kind of melody and harmony you like. In fact one reason I avoid CSound is that it's still a little too traditional for my liking - in particular, the similarity that i-statements have with the traditional idea of a 'note' with a certain duration.

However, the lower-level a tool you choose, the more work you typically have to do yourself to get things sounding nice - and it may be fair to say that "out-of-the-box", Csound instruments don't tend to sound as obviously pretty as the best patches on a typical VST or hardware synthesizer - and the workflow might not be as immediately fun as mucking around with those.

I would also agree that the priorities of a composer who has come to CSound might be atypical. But IIRC it's a fairly simple thing to set up a couple of instrument sounds and get some 'proper tunes' going. There are plenty of alternatives though when it comes to coding languages though - sonic Pi is one that I recently saw demonstrated impressively.