: (Conflict) Kostka/Payne Cadence Chart vs. Authentic Cadence in Natural Minor According to Is this generic cadence chart from Kostka/Payne generally accepted?, However, the authentic cadence in natural minor, which

Vote Up Vote Down   0 Reactions

Login to give Reaction!

(Conflict) Kostka/Payne Cadence Chart vs. Authentic Cadence in Natural Minor
According to Is this generic cadence chart from Kostka/Payne generally accepted?,

However, the authentic cadence in natural minor, which is v-i, does not meet the definition by Kostka/Payne here. The first chord, v, doesn't really contain the leading tone (as the subtonic and the leading tone are two completely different concepts), while the second chord, i, is the tonic. In this view, it seems to be more plagal, but it isn't.

So, why is v-i in natural minor viewed as an authentic cadence while it doesn't fit the definition by Kostka/Payne?

(0)

Login to post a comment!