Is it a usual practice from pianists to remove the hand that does not play during a certain time, far from the keyboard?
Is it a usual practice from piano concertists to remove the specific hand far from the keyboard when this hand does not currently play for a certain duration, instead of keeping the hand just "above" the keyboard ?
Is is a recommendation from their teachers and/or schools ? Is it for artistic reasons or for "making some buzz" ? What is the goal ?
See this example :
until 00:25, Valentina very oftens removes completely the left hand from the keyboard when the left hand does not play, while she could also have kept it "above" the keyboard, at the position of either the last key or the next key.
(4)4 Comments
Sorted by latest first Latest Oldest Best
There's no standard practice for what you do with the hand that's not playing. Some players leave the hand hovering over the keys, some rest it on their lap, some wave the hand theatrically in the air. Do whatever feels right.
What she's doing is perfectly normal and acceptable, but not required.
There cannot be a definitive answer for this!
Some do, some don't.
Some do in certain pieces, some don't.
The music itself may impel a player to, or not as the case may be.
'In the moment' is when that decision is often made - dependent on where in the piece, how the player feels, how the audience is reacting, how it's going. And, no doubt, several other factors too.
The 'rule' says 'do what you want, when you want'...
To be honest, if that's all a performer is thinking about in the middle of a piece - what??
One of my teachers cultivated this habit in me. She said that if you hold your hand/arm up to the keyboard in a static load position it creates tension. Raising your arm back up initiates the gravitational forces and aids in timing. So, unused hands go in my lap. I would never dangle my arm to the side because that creates a pull which might be opposite of the direction I am playing. The fingers, hand, arm, body, can only go in one direction at a time. Try to pull in two directions simultaneously and tension will ensue.
This is an excellent video. Witness her pronator and supinator muscles rotating the whole arm. Don't watch her hands, watch her elbow. That is where technique comes from, not the fingers. Her pronator teres is so defined that it makes a dent in her arm.
Great, now I have to go practice. Curses.
Terms of Use Privacy policy Contact About Cancellation policy © freshhoot.com2026 All Rights reserved.