bell notificationshomepageloginNewPostedit profiledmBox

Hoots : Recording rhythm pauses that throw off the count I'm quite new to recording and best practices. At the moment I'm enjoying learning through recording existing songs I'm playing myself. One song is in 8/4 (in my opinion) - freshhoot.com

10% popularity   0 Reactions

Recording rhythm pauses that throw off the count
I'm quite new to recording and best practices. At the moment I'm enjoying learning through recording existing songs I'm playing myself.

One song is in 8/4 (in my opinion) but has an extra (loose) half beat at the very end of the bar that's just silence, like a quick breath. This only occurs for the first few bars when it's just a single acoustic guitar and vocals.

When I play this song on guitar without recording, it feels easy to incorporate this into playing. It's just a natural timing choice that adds feeling to the song. But I've no idea how to approach this with recording? I'm learning to play along with the metronome in headphones and I miss this pause when I stick to a strict bar count. It feels like I'm rushing into the next bar. But, as I said, it's loosely done and not a case of adding an exact count into my DAW. In the original recording, after a few bars it disappears and sticks strictly to 8/4 when a full band comes in.

What is the best way of approaching this? I'm wondering if this type of recording usually forgoes a metronome as it's too unpredictable, even though the majority of the bar is on count.


Load Full (1)

Login to follow hoots

1 Comments

Sorted by latest first Latest Oldest Best

10% popularity   0 Reactions

Both of the first two comments offer excellent information and advice. I would suggest splitting the difference between them and record the first section without click or with the click muted. When the time starts and the band comes in play to the click for the rest of the song.

If you prefer to program the loose last beats most every DAW has a tempo list or something similar. This is how I would do it assuming the song is in 8/4 at 100bpm and slows to 90bpm and I want to program bars 2 and 3:

Tempo List

Bar/Beat Tempo

1 1 100

2 8 90

3 1 100

3 8 90

4 1 100

I have had success programming these types of tempo changes but when the time is fluid it is usually better to just play it how you feel and not try and line up to a grid.


Back to top Use Dark theme