Question from non-musician: Is it possible to learn sight-singing without having learned an instrument?
I'm trying to learn sight-singing sheet music. I understand the basics such as the length of a note, time signatures and so on. But the only insurmountable difficulty for me is that I don't remember the pitch of the notes on the staff. It takes me more than a few seconds after I see a note to figure out how high its pitch should be. I know that people who have learned a musical instrument such as the piano have instant reflexes when they see a note, because they have played those notes thousands of times. But I don't have this ability.
A lot of people claim it is possible to learn sight-singing sheet music without having learned an instrument, but I've grown ever suspicious, because I had once tried quite hard to remember the notes, with no success. I've learned where the notes are located on a keyboard, but again all I have done is learning theory, and I never managed to develop an ability to instantly recognize a note as shown on the staff.
So do you think it's a valid idea at all for me to try to learn sight-singing, before I have time to learn an instrument? I'm sorry this question is a little dumb for most people on this board.
(3)3 Comments
Sorted by latest first Latest Oldest Best
First of all, are you trying to figure out the pitch of a note simply by seeing? As in seeing seeing a C# on the staff then being able to sing a C# exactly on pitch without an instrument? This ability is called perfect pitch, and most people, including myself, do not possess this ability. What most good musicians (including singers) have is good relative pitch, which is to be able to sing or hum a melody from sheet music after the starting note has been given. In any case, to be a good sight-singer requires some ear training, also known as aural training. You would start by learning to recognize intervals, i.e., the distance between notes, by ear. Combine this with the ability to recognize the intervals on the staff, and you should be able to, with practice, sight-sing fairly easily. Now, is it necessary to learn in instrument? I believe, with consistent practice, it is entirely possible to to learn to sight-sing well without learning an instrument. However, most people I know who are good sight-singers know at least one instrument, usually the piano.
I liked Daryl's answer, and would add that many of my students who don't play an instrument have found using solfege (do, re, mi) with a teacher helpful in learning to sight-sing.
I am learning to sight sing too. The best thing is to contact your local Kodaly Academy as they run all sorts of courses that will help you internalise pitch, and give you exercises to help you take any key and accidentals in your stride. If you live in Britain or the States there's regular residentials, weekly lessons, etc. I've managed to go from nothing to intermediate level by doing this. They use solfa in a very good way.
Terms of Use Privacy policy Contact About Cancellation policy © freshhoot.com2025 All Rights reserved.